9 May 2025

Trump and Vance Choose to Stay Neutral Amid Escalating Tensions Between India and Pakistan

With ongoing cricket match suspensions, power outages, and air-raid sirens, fears are escalating about an all-out war between India and Pakistan. The situation has raised questions regarding the effectiveness of the United States in mediating between the two nuclear-armed nations. Recent violence has intensified, marking the worst clashes in decades.

India launched military strikes in response to a deadly terrorist attack for which it holds Pakistan responsible. The initial conflict resulted in the deaths of nearly 40 individuals from both sides, as India targeted perceived “terror camps,” while Pakistan denied involvement in the attack that took place on April 22 in the contested region of Kashmir. Accusations have continued to fly between the countries.

On Friday, both nations reported new offensives, with Pakistan accusing India of shelling its towns and causing civilian casualties, while India claimed to have thwarted drone attacks from Pakistan. This ongoing violence has forced villagers near the de facto border in Kashmir to evacuate their homes. The sporting realm has also been affected; the Indian Premier League was suspended due to safety concerns amid the conflict.

U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio has attempted to intervene, speaking with officials from both countries. He expressed condolences for the terrorist attack in Kashmir and labeled the United States as a partner in fighting terrorism. Rubio also urged Pakistan to cease its support for terrorist groups.

However, sentiments in India suggest skepticism about foreign mediation, with officials asserting that the issues are bilateral and focused on counter-terrorism. In contrast, Pakistan described India’s military actions as provocations and argued that its responses were essential for self-defense. The U.S. has traditionally played a significant role in de-escalating India-Pakistan tensions, yet its relations with Pakistan have soured, leading to uncertainty about its influence.

Nevertheless, U.S. officials indicate openness to investigating the recent terrorist attack, reiterating the need for accountability for those responsible. The broader conflict over Kashmir remains complex, steeped in decades of division and mutual distrust between the two nations.