9 May 2025

Catholic Americans Celebrate the Legacy of Pope Leo XIV’s Leadership and Impact

VATICAN CITY — The newly elected American pope received an enthusiastic and distinctly American welcome in Vatican City. “USA!

USA! USA!” echoed loudly from a lively crowd of young clergymen in St. Peter’s Square.

Once a serene space for contemplation, the square took on the atmosphere of a sporting event after Vatican officials announced Cardinal Robert Francis Prevost as the first American-born pope, now known as Pope Leo XIV. Many Americans present felt a mix of surprise and pride.

Joe Brodeur, a 27-year-old deacon from Rhode Island, expressed his bewilderment, saying, “I am shocked. I am feeling so much joy, that’s all I can say.” However, confusion reigned initially when the announcement was made in Latin; many in the crowd struggled to catch the name amid the commotion.

As the news of Prevost’s selection spread, reactions varied. Alec Maddox, a consultant living in San Diego, admitted excitement but also a lack of knowledge about the new pope, stating, “I’m ecstatic,” alongside his brothers.

They all shared a desire for a pope who adheres to traditional doctrine, reflecting a sentiment among some Catholics who were critical of the previous pope’s progressive approach. Rebecca Tabiani, a New Jersey native residing in Rome, expressed disappointment at the choice, voicing a concern regarding American influence in the Vatican.

“I think it should have gone elsewhere,” she remarked. Conversely, Matthew Laferty, an American director of an ecumenical office in Rome, noted that Prevost’s election indicated potential compromise among the cardinals.

The atmosphere in St. Peter’s Square was marked by a shared sense of joy, with people from diverse backgrounds celebrating together. News cameras captured celebrations back in the United States as churchgoers at St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York City erupted in applause when the new pope was announced.

Many voiced hopes that Pope Leo XIV would continue the legacy of inclusiveness initiated by his predecessor, fostering a revival of faith among younger generations.